Free rental-property guide
Rental property expense checklist
A rental can look strong because a cost is absent, not because the economics are resilient. Use this checklist to give every expense an explicit answer before you trust the cash flow, cap rate, cash-on-cash return, or maximum offer.
Rule 1
A blank line is not evidence of zero cost.
Rule 2
Keep routine repairs and major replacements separate.
Rule 3
Stress-test the lines that can reverse the decision.
Before the checklist
Write down how your model treats income, NOI, CapEx, and debt.
Two models can use the same inputs and still disagree because they classify costs differently. DulyCheck states its convention so the result can be challenged.
Vacancy is deducted from gross rent. Management is charged on collected rent. Maintenance and the CapEx reserve are charged on gross rent.
NOI excludes debt service and the CapEx reserve. Pre-tax cash flow equals NOI minus the CapEx reserve minus debt service. Read the full rules on the DulyCheck method page.
Checklist 01
Income reductions before expenses
Start with the rent you expect to collect, not just the lease amount or listing estimate.
Vacancy
Model: Model time without rent between tenants and any seasonal or market-specific vacancy risk.
Evidence: Current lease history, local vacancy evidence, property-manager input, and realistic turnover timing.
Collection loss
Model: Separate unpaid or delayed rent from physical vacancy when the tenant profile or operating history makes it relevant.
Evidence: Rent ledger, payment history, arrears, concessions, and actual collections rather than scheduled rent alone.
Concessions and free-rent periods
Model: Include move-in incentives, free weeks, renewal concessions, or other reductions needed to obtain the modeled rent.
Evidence: Executed lease, leasing advertisement, property-manager quote, or documented local practice.
Other income reliability
Model: Treat parking, storage, laundry, pet rent, utility reimbursements, and similar income as separate assumptions.
Evidence: Lease clauses, operating statements, payment history, and evidence that the charge is legal and collectible.
Checklist 02
Recurring property operating costs
These costs usually continue whether the property is occupied, vacant, self-managed, or professionally managed.
Property taxes
Model: Use the expected bill after purchase, including possible reassessment, local assessments, and multiple taxing authorities.
Evidence: Current tax bill, assessor information, closing estimate, and jurisdiction-specific reassessment research.
Landlord insurance
Model: Price the actual intended use, deductible, liability limits, hazard exposure, and any flood, wind, earthquake, or umbrella coverage.
Evidence: Current written quote for the exact property and strategy, not the seller's old premium or a generic estimate.
HOA or condo charges
Model: Include regular dues and separately investigate reserves, pending increases, rental restrictions, and special assessments.
Evidence: Current statement, budget, reserve study, meeting minutes, rules, declarations, and resale package.
Owner-paid utilities
Model: Account for water, sewer, trash, gas, electricity, internet, common-area power, or master-metered services paid by the owner.
Evidence: Twelve months of bills where available, lease allocation, utility-provider rates, and occupancy assumptions.
Exterior and site services
Model: Include landscaping, snow removal, pool service, pest control, security, private roads, septic, well, or storm-water obligations when applicable.
Evidence: Vendor quotes, service agreements, property history, inspection findings, and local requirements.
Licenses and inspections
Model: Check rental registration, business licenses, local inspections, short-term-rental permits, and recurring compliance fees.
Evidence: Municipal rules, fee schedules, permit records, and confirmation that the intended rental strategy is allowed.
Accounting, legal, and banking
Model: Include recurring bookkeeping, tax preparation, entity, legal, payment-processing, and bank costs that belong to the property operation.
Evidence: Actual service pricing, current agreements, and a clear rule for which portfolio-level costs are allocated to this property.
Miscellaneous recurring costs
Model: Capture any recurring line that does not fit elsewhere, then name it clearly instead of hiding it in a broad percentage.
Evidence: Invoice, contract, historical statement, or a written conservative assumption with an owner and review date.
Checklist 03
Management, leasing, and tenant-turn costs
A property can be self-managed today and professionally managed later. Model the operating reality you need the deal to survive.
Ongoing management
Model: Include the fee structure, minimum charges, maintenance markups, and whether the percentage is applied to scheduled or collected rent.
Evidence: Written management proposal or current agreement for the property type and market.
Leasing or tenant-placement fees
Model: Model the cost of advertising, showings, screening, lease preparation, and placement each time a tenant turns over.
Evidence: Property-manager fee schedule and a realistic turnover frequency.
Renewal and inspection fees
Model: Include recurring renewal, annual inspection, notice, coordination, or technology charges when the manager bills them separately.
Evidence: Full management fee schedule, not just the headline monthly percentage.
Turnover work
Model: Budget cleaning, paint touch-ups, locks, minor repairs, trash removal, utilities during vacancy, and lost days between tenants.
Evidence: Prior turns, local vendor pricing, unit condition, and lease deposit rules.
Tenant-default and legal process
Model: Decide whether your normal maintenance reserve can absorb notices, legal fees, court costs, property damage, and extended nonpayment.
Evidence: Local attorney guidance, management process, landlord-law requirements, and an explicit contingency rather than an assumed zero.
Checklist 04
Maintenance, capital replacements, and reserves
Routine maintenance and major replacements are different economic problems. Keeping them separate makes thin deals easier to see.
Routine maintenance
Model: Model ordinary repairs and service calls that keep the property operating, such as plumbing, electrical, appliance, hardware, and minor exterior work.
Evidence: Property age and condition, inspection findings, maintenance history, and local labor pricing.
Capital expenditure reserve
Model: Set aside for longer-life replacements such as roof, HVAC, water heater, exterior systems, appliances, paving, or major plumbing and electrical work.
Evidence: Remaining useful life, replacement scope, current quotes, warranties, and a component-level reserve schedule where practical.
Immediate rehab
Model: Keep pre-rent or post-close work separate from recurring maintenance so cash-to-close and stabilization timing remain visible.
Evidence: Written scope, contractor quotes, permits, contingency, holding period, and who is responsible for overruns.
Emergency liquidity
Model: Decide how much cash must remain available after closing for deductibles, uninsured losses, vacancy, failed equipment, and timing gaps.
Evidence: Insurance deductibles, lender reserve requirements, property condition, household liquidity, and portfolio concentration.
Deferred maintenance inherited at purchase
Model: Identify work the seller postponed even when it is not yet a formal inspection defect or contractor line item.
Evidence: Inspection, seller disclosures, maintenance records, photos, service history, and specialist opinions when needed.
Checklist 05
Financing and cash-to-close costs
A deal can produce acceptable property-level income and still fail because the financing or initial cash requirement was modeled incorrectly.
Principal and interest
Model: Use the actual loan amount, rate, amortization, and payment structure. Separate interest-only periods, balloons, and adjustable-rate behavior.
Evidence: Current written lender terms tied to the expected closing date.
Points and lender fees
Model: Include origination, discount points, underwriting, processing, appraisal, legal, inspection, and other lender charges.
Evidence: Loan estimate, term sheet, lender fee schedule, and clarification of refundable versus nonrefundable items.
Closing costs and prepaids
Model: Include title, escrow, recording, transfer charges, legal costs, prepaid taxes and insurance, and initial escrow funding.
Evidence: Current closing estimate and local transaction practice.
Lender reserves and covenants
Model: Model required cash reserves, repair escrows, replacement reserves, debt-service coverage rules, and future reporting obligations.
Evidence: Final loan documents and written lender confirmation.
Refinance or bridge assumptions
Model: Do not treat a future refinance, rate reduction, appraisal, or sale as guaranteed cash. Test whether the property survives if that event is delayed or unavailable.
Evidence: Current takeout criteria, conservative value and income assumptions, maturity date, extension terms, and alternative liquidity plan.
Checklist 06
Strategy-specific and exit costs
The intended rental strategy can create costs that a standard long-term-rental model does not capture automatically.
Short-term or furnished operation
Model: Include platform fees, cleaning, linens, supplies, furnishing replacement, utilities, internet, local occupancy taxes, permits, and seasonal vacancy.
Evidence: Actual platform statements, local regulations, management quote, furnishing schedule, and market-specific seasonality.
Multi-unit or common-area operation
Model: Include common-area utilities, turnover by unit, shared systems, fire and safety requirements, trash, grounds, and unit-specific leasing costs.
Evidence: Rent roll, leases, utility allocation, code records, inspection, and trailing operating statements.
Selling and disposition costs
Model: Keep commissions, transfer charges, legal or title costs, repairs, concessions, and taxes visible in any future exit analysis.
Evidence: Local transaction costs, tax advice, expected hold period, and a conservative sale scenario.
Inflation and multi-year changes
Model: A first-year model is not a full hold-period forecast. Consider how taxes, insurance, labor, utilities, rent, financing, and major replacements may change over time.
Evidence: Historical bills, policy renewal behavior, actual market data, lease terms, and scenario ranges rather than one precise forecast.
Illustrative decision flip
A $350 monthly cushion can disappear when five $0 lines receive values.
This example does not prescribe the correct percentage for a particular property. It shows why a model should make every assumption visible and then replace estimates with property-specific evidence.
| Line | Illustrative assumption | Monthly effect |
|---|---|---|
| Starting modeled cash flow | Before the omitted lines below | +$350.00 |
| Vacancy | 5% of $2,200 gross rent | -$110.00 |
| Management | 8% of $2,090 collected rent | -$167.20 |
| Routine maintenance | 5% of gross rent | -$110.00 |
| CapEx reserve | 5% of gross rent | -$110.00 |
| Owner-paid service | One recurring utility or site-service line | -$75.00 |
| Revised modeled cash flow | Same property, more explicit assumptions | -$222.20 |
Five evidence states
The number and the strength of its support are separate questions.
Use one of these states for every material assumption. Do not promote an estimate simply because it was copied into a spreadsheet or extracted from a document.
Documented
Direct source document or record for the exact line.
Supported
Credible support that is relevant but not the final direct proof.
Estimated
Reasoned estimate with a stated basis and review date.
Assumed
A placeholder chosen without enough supporting evidence yet.
Missing
No usable value or basis is currently available.
A 15-minute first pass
Use the checklist without turning it into another spreadsheet project.
- 01
Mark every line as included, intentionally $0, unknown, or not applicable. Do not allow a blank cell to answer the question for you.
- 02
Attach the strongest source you already have, then label the evidence as Documented, Supported, Estimated, Assumed, or Missing.
- 03
Recalculate the deal with conservative placeholders for the important unknowns. Focus on whether the conclusion changes, not whether the estimate looks precise.
- 04
Work the evidence gaps in order of decision impact. A small unsupported line may matter less than a rent, insurance, tax, financing, or replacement assumption with almost no cushion.
Questions investors ask
Rental expense checklist FAQ
Is the mortgage payment a rental property operating expense?
No. In DulyCheck's stated convention, principal and interest are debt service, not operating expenses. NOI is calculated before debt service. Pre-tax cash flow then subtracts the CapEx reserve and debt service from NOI.
Are maintenance and CapEx the same thing?
No. Maintenance covers ordinary repairs and service work that keep the property operating. CapEx is a reserve for longer-life replacements such as a roof, HVAC system, water heater, paving, or major building systems. Combining them can hide whether the reserve is adequate for the property's age and condition.
Should I include management if I plan to manage the property myself?
At minimum, run a scenario with professional management. Your time has an economic cost, and the property may need outside management later. A deal that works only because management is permanently modeled at $0 has less operating flexibility.
What vacancy percentage should I use?
There is no universal percentage that fits every property. Use local evidence, the property's operating history, tenant profile, seasonality, leasing time, and management input. Keep the assumption visible and test how much vacancy the deal can absorb before cash flow or your target return fails.
What should I do when an expense is truly $0?
Keep it at $0 only after confirming why. Record whether the cost is paid by the tenant, included in another line, prohibited by the strategy, covered by an agreement, or intentionally self-performed. A documented zero is different from a blank or forgotten zero.
Move from checklist to property workspace
Put the actual deal through the math, evidence, and downside checks.
DulyCheck keeps the expense lines visible, shows which assumptions have weak support, calculates how much adverse movement the deal can absorb, and helps prioritize the next document or diligence question. It does not tell you to buy or sell.
This checklist is an analytical and diligence aid. Costs, legal obligations, tax treatment, insurance requirements, lending terms, and local rules vary by property and jurisdiction. Confirm material items through the relevant documents, professionals, public agencies, and service providers before committing capital.